“Top-notch” “each and every time”, this “small” Carle Place Italian attracts adoring amici willing to go “out of the way” for “heavenly” “old-line” cuisine (including “wonderful whole fish”) “served with style” by “warm hosts” who look after you like “their only customer”; it’s “pretty pricey” and “worth every penny”, but “they don’t have room for a crowd”, so “don’t tell.”